The pitfalls of employee suggestion programs

Add bookmark

I wrote in last month's column, there is no doubt that organizations need to do a far better job of tapping into the human capital of their team members as a vehicle to drive improvements and innovation. Unfortunately, too many organizations may have such policies in place but don’t actually make it real in their business.

One retiree from the automotive sector once commented on the day of his retirement, "you paid me to do my job for over 35 years and you could have had my brain for free".

As process improvement professionals, we recognize the importance of capturing the ideas of team members that are closest to the process, yet what can we do to make it more routine?

Is is possible to make ideas and innovation routine?

A common approach that organizations implement is to create an employee suggestion program. While this is often a great concept, suggestion programs continue to treat the idea generation as an exceptional event as opposed to a way of doing things.

Additionally, these programs are often plagued with high volumes of poor quality ideas (that either take a significant amount of effort to implement or don’t get implemented and result in team member apathy) for only a few golden nuggets.

When financial rewards are incorporated, these programs can create new layers of complexity around awarding incentives and occasionally create conflict when several teams feel they had a similar idea. By paying for "good ideas" we’re essentially communicating that by coming to work we’re not expecting you to use your brain and generate ideas.

So what other options exist?

For one, every effort should be made to turn the idea generation process into a regular pattern whereby each leader has regular dialogues around generating improvements to the process. And by involving team members in not only the idea generation but also the piloting process, we’re now also improving the quality of the ideas as team members rapidly see what the impact of their suggestion was.

Idea suggestion programs could then be integrated with such broad based team engagement techniques to help capture and address opportunities that are more cross-functional in nature.

Additionally, consideration could be given to certain social media tools that can capture ideas and allow team members to cross-functionally vote ideas up or down based on their particular vantage point. This helps simplify the selection process while mobilizing a larger number of team members in the process.

What methods have you seen work to better tap into the ideas and innovations of your team members?


Upcoming Events

Business Transformation World Summit

January 26 - 28, 2026

Hyatt Regency Miami, Florida, US

Business Transformation World Summit

All Access: Future of BPM 2026

10 February 2026

Free PEX Network Webinar Series

All Access: Future of BPM 2026

The Connected Worker: Energy Summit

March 23 - 25, 2026

The Westin Galleria Houston, Texas

The Connected Worker: Energy Summit

All Access: AI in PEX 2026

March 24 - 25, 2026

Free PEX Network Webinar Series

All Access: AI in PEX 2026

All Access: Process Intelligence 2026

April 14 - 15, 2026

Free PEX Network Webinar Series

All Access: Process Intelligence 2026

Latest Webinars

New KPIs for a new era: How AI elevates operations

2026-01-28

11:00 AM - 12:00 PM EST

Explore the AI-driven metrics that matter most for modern operations teams — and how new KPIs improv...

Stop repeat outages: Save millions by eliminating change-related incidents

2026-01-22

11:00 AM - 12:00 PM EST

Stop change-related incidents with AI-powered change management and proactive governance that boosts...

End-to-end portfolio and asset management transformation with Powerco and TNB

2025-12-17

11:00 AM - 12:00 PM SGT

This session goes beyond theory, offering concrete examples of how two transmission and distribution...

Recommended